Kevin De Young’s recent lecture on Christian Nationalism really is an attack on not only Kinism but also theonomic postmillennialism. He attacks a “new postmillennialism.” That newer postillennialism understood that their was a connection between God’s people living in terms of God’s revealed law-Word (third use of the law) and the advance of the Kingdom of God. De Young bitterly complains about this “new postmillennialism,” saying that previously amillennialists like himself and postmillennialists really weren’t that different.
From there De Young insists that he is an optimistic amillennialist. But where is the optimism? It certainly is not found in the idea that the knowledge of the Lord will cover the earth as the earth covers the sea. It certainly not in the conviction that Christ shall reign UNTIL He makes His enemies His footstool. It certainly is not wrapped up in the declaration that the “Kings must Kiss the son, lest they perish in the way.” Except in asserting optimism where is you optimism Kevin? Where is the evidence that you are optimistic besides your just saying, “I really am optimistic.”
What we see here from Kevin is what we see from so many Amillennialists today and that is a rabid militancy against any notion of working towards the reality that Christ, having dominion, shall have dominion. Kev is all “not yet,” in his eschatology (like all Amils) with no, “now,” in his eschatology and because of that the one group he wants to inveigh against in the Church are those who do have a “now” that goes with their eschatological, “not yet.”
Paraphrasing young Augustine: “God, make me optimistic, but NOT YET!”
“… The march of Providence is so slow, and our desire so impatient, the work of progress is so immense, and our means of aiding it so feeble, the life of humanity is so long, and that of the individual so brief, that we often see only the ebb of the advancing wave, and are thus discouraged. It is history that teaches us to hope”
— General Robert E. Lee, after The War