Indicative & Imperative Preaching

“If the indicative is permitted to predominate to the exclusion of the imperative, preaching will inevitably tend in the direction of quietism or antinomianism. If the imperative is permitted to predominate to the exclusion of the indicative, the preaching will inevitably tend in the direction of moralism and legalism.”

Dr. John Carrick
The Imperative of Preaching, p. 146

The indicative is what God has done for us outside of us in Christ. It is the necessary reminder that in Christ there is therefore now no condemnation. Believers need to be constantly reminded of the indicative since we tend either to put confidence in our behavior as contributory to Justification or we despair since we are conversant with our own sinfulness. God’s people need to regularly have the indicative preached into them.

The imperative is the reminder of what God does inside of us as result of being indwelt by the Spirit of Christ. The imperative answers the question that all Christ lovers ask, “How shall we now live.” The imperative preaches, “Now that you are safely in Christ because of His finished work, this is how would God have you to live as ‘holy and beloved.'” Imperative preaching often appeals to the law as a “guide to life” and reveals what God’s mind is for His people on a host of subjects.

The Good News of the Gospel is both what God has done for us outside of us in Christ and what God, by His indwelling Spirit, is doing to conform us to Christ.

Disagreements about this is what lies behind the ongoing revolt in Reformed churches against Radical Two Kingdom theology. R2K emphasis Redemptive Historical Preaching (Indicative) to the complete neglect of Imperative preaching. R2K ministers divide Christ from His office of High Priest and His office of High King. R2K preaches a Christ who saves but abominate a Christ who rules over His people in the public realm. This dividing Christ’s offices is why R2K is heresy.

There has been, in history, heretical offerings that concentrated on Imperative preaching. Richard Baxter’s and much later John MacArthur’s preaching was “Neo-nomian” as seen in his book, “The Gospel According To Jesus.” Neo-nomianism (new law) also saturates Federal Vision “theology.” These chaps make Justification dependent upon sanctification thus making our doing necessarily required as being contributory to what Christ did.

Indeed, the long running contest between R2K and Federal Vision was a long study in two heresies each denouncing the other even though both were (and remain) heresies. However, R2K chaps like R. Scott Clark have even denounced orthodox men like Mark Jones in the past because Clark’s Indicative driven antinomianism was contrary to Mark Jones insisting that good works, though not contributory toward Justification are involved in salvation.

This distinction between Indicative and Imperative preaching is also really what is behind the revolt against the idea that nations should be and can be Christian. Indicative preaching tends to be very individualistic in terms of soteriology. Per Indicative preaching Individuals are saved. Nations are not. As such Redemptive-Historical preaching seldom has a category for the renewal of all things except as that happens in the eschaton. Even here though, R2K mavens like David Van Drunen has argued that there is no post fall cultural mandate, insisting that while individuals can be redeemed, cultures and nations can not. This is in keeping with a purist form of Indicative preaching.

It is the case that the imperatives are anchored in the Indicative. Because Christ is our propitiation and reconciliation with God, believers, out of a sense of deep abiding gratitude, desire to know and live in keeping with God’s revealed law (in its second use) as filled with the Holy Spirit. Believer’s understand that their ever increasing, though never perfect, walking in obedience is in no way an avenue to secure an un-certain Justification. Rather, Believer’s understand that being secure in a certain and unchangeable Justification, they are now free to increasingly become what they have been freely declared to be, in Christ.

This explains, in part, why the modern Reformed Church is in such a mess right now. Much of the clergy is dividing truths that never should have been divided.

Author: jetbrane

I am a Pastor of a small Church in Mid-Michigan who delights in my family, my congregation and my calling. I am postmillennial in my eschatology. Paedo-Calvinist Covenantal in my Christianity Reformed in my Soteriology Presuppositional in my apologetics Familialist in my family theology Agrarian in my regional community social order belief Christianity creates culture and so Christendom in my national social order belief Mythic-Poetic / Grammatical Historical in my Hermeneutic Pre-modern, Medieval, & Feudal before Enlightenment, modernity, & postmodern Reconstructionist / Theonomic in my Worldview One part paleo-conservative / one part micro Libertarian in my politics Systematic and Biblical theology need one another but Systematics has pride of place Some of my favorite authors, Augustine, Turretin, Calvin, Tolkien, Chesterton, Nock, Tozer, Dabney, Bavinck, Wodehouse, Rushdoony, Bahnsen, Schaeffer, C. Van Til, H. Van Til, G. H. Clark, C. Dawson, H. Berman, R. Nash, C. G. Singer, R. Kipling, G. North, J. Edwards, S. Foote, F. Hayek, O. Guiness, J. Witte, M. Rothbard, Clyde Wilson, Mencken, Lasch, Postman, Gatto, T. Boston, Thomas Brooks, Terry Brooks, C. Hodge, J. Calhoun, Llyod-Jones, T. Sowell, A. McClaren, M. Muggeridge, C. F. H. Henry, F. Swarz, M. Henry, G. Marten, P. Schaff, T. S. Elliott, K. Van Hoozer, K. Gentry, etc. My passion is to write in such a way that the Lord Christ might be pleased. It is my hope that people will be challenged to reconsider what are considered the givens of the current culture. Your biggest help to me dear reader will be to often remind me that God is Sovereign and that all that is, is because it pleases him.

2 thoughts on “Indicative & Imperative Preaching”

  1. Yes.
    In the idiom of classical philosophy, we speak of the IS and the OUGHT.
    We note how every IS — whether God or one of His creatures — contains within itself or within Himself (if God) OUGHTS. Hence the connection between metaphysics and morals.
    God always or invariably thinks and does what He ought because the oughts of His willing are performed in His always and freely choosing the best.

    In the idiom of grammar, we speak of the three moods: indicative, imperative, and subjunctive. Statements in the indicative mood are statements of fact (or of purported fact). Statements in the imperative are commands. And statements in the subjunctive mood are about possibility, typically expressed in conditional form with express protasis-apodosis clauses. Statements in these three moods, reflecting the structure of reality, are mutually exclusive and jointly exhaustive of all possible coherent statements.

    IS and OUGHT are ontically inextricably intertwined, in creation because in the Creator. Preaching that focusses on one to the exclusion of the other is necessarily barren and essentially false and misleading. An OUGHT unrooted in an IS is an OUGHT without moorings or coherence or content. An IS without an OUGHT would be a being or existent without purpose. In God, Who is and contains all possible perfections, and in this, His best of all possible worlds, the erroneous separation of IS and OUGHT occurs only in the thinking of finite men and the fallen angels.

  2. Thank you for holding these two truths together so clearly, since neither one can stand well without the other. What God has done for us in Christ gives real rest to the conscience, and what He works within us then shapes how we live each day. This is a helpful reminder to preach both with confidence and to keep returning to grace as the ground for obedience.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *