Only the most high Rev. Wilson observes; whereas “Revoice” was about side-b sodomy, those of us who agree with our Fathers on the issue of the Bagels are side-b Nazis. According to Pope Doug we who agree with our Fathers on the Bagel issue are trying to be “sin-adjacent.” True, per Pope Doug, we don’t want to be out right Nazis but we do want to be kind of like that. Why some of us even have the temerity to agree with Dr. R. J. Rushdoony, David Irving, and many others that the genocide numbers may well have been inflated. Indeed, per Doug it seems that it may well be a sin to not only inquire too closely about the actual number total of deaths but it is even the case that it is beyond the pale to even contemplate the possibility that International Jewry had an agenda that was decidedly against the German people. One wonders if Doug has ever read about the boycott against German goods called for by International Jewry in March of 1933?
So, in Doug’s brain any honest attempt at historical revision automatically falls under the category of a Nazi version of revoice where Christians see how close they can get to Nazism without actually becoming Nazis. Of course, by this standard, Augustine, Chrysostom, Luther and Calvin and many Church councils were the original version of Revoice that folks like Sam Alberry, Nate Collins and Misty Irons copied in 2018.
Of course, Doug, as he typically does, leaves himself an out by saying, after he rips people who question the WW II narrative, that he has been questioning the WW II narrative for decades. Yeah, it sure shows Doug.
Doug wants to accuse these young chaps of being a Nazi version of “Side-B Sodomy.” Very well then, I accuse Doug of being the embodiment of C. S. Lewis’ “Green Witch” in the Narnia book “The Silver Chair.” If you will remember in that novel, Prince Rilian, has been seduced and enchanted to serve the ends of the Green Witch. However, the spell is never complete and daily the Prince is required to sit in the Silver Chair in order to get his daily fix of enchantment that will keep him beholden to the Green Witch. One day, in the presence of Jill, Eustace, and Puddleglum, Prince Rilian incrementally awakens from the spell and begins to rail and rage against The Green Witch and her spell upon him. At this point the Green Witch enters into the room they are all in and begins to sing again her spell of enchantment in order to put the Prince back to sleep and so under her spell.
Doug is playing the Green Witch. Young men are waking up to how much and how often they’ve been lied to by the Governmental-Corporate-Ecclesiastical-Media complex. In this awakening everything is being questioned from the post-Enlightenment/ WW II consensus forward. People are discovering that for centuries, if not millennium Jewish and Biblical Christian interests have been at severe cross purposes. Yet, in this awakening there we find guys like Doug Wilson seeking to reinvigorate the spell that has had us all sleeping for decades and has had us serving as lackeys for the purposes of an Institutional Green Witch that is contrary to our own Christian and National interests.
Now, to be sure, there are voices out there that are excessive on this subject. For example, some of the work, that the Lutherans, Mahler and Woe, are doing is positively unhinged. Keep in mind though that the swing back of this pendulum may be particularly vicious given the resentment and rage over being lied to for decades. If the snap back is extreme guys like Wilson (Andrew Sandlin, Karl Trueman to name a couple more) have to share the blame. Forcing the lid down on a boiling pot only guarantees that the whole pot is sure top explode.
Doug Wilson on this subject (and more than a few others) is the Green Witch seeking to put the young Princes of the realm back to sleep.
And myself?
I’m just trying to play the role of faithful Puddleglum by casting myself on the fire that is aiding in the Green Witch’s enchantment. I can only hope that burnt McAtee smells as head clearing as burnt Marshwiggle.
Addendum
I would strongly recommend that Doug read the following books. It is only a start.
E. Michael Jones — The Jewish Revolutionary Spirit
E. Michael Jones — The Holocaust Narrative
Maurice Pinay — The Plot Against The Church
Hillarie Belloc — The Jews
Martin Luther — The Jews and Their Lies
John Calvin — Response to Question and Objections of a Certain Jew
Against the Jews — Chrysostom
“Now, to be sure, there are voices out there that are excessive on this subject. For example, some of the work, that the Lutherans, Mahler and Woe, are doing is positively unhinged. Keep in mind though that the swing back of this pendulum may be particularly vicious given the resentment and rage over being lied to for decades.”
And yet, precisely at such “pendulum swings” one has to be mindful of Satan’s wiles. Apostle Paul said “we are not ignorant of his devices” in the context (2. Cor. 2:11) where the Christian converts had laudably given up their former laxity and excessive tolerance of sin, but were now in danger of becoming overly judgmental and mean-spirited by rushing to the opposite extreme.
As the old John Gill commentary put it:
https://biblehub.com/commentaries/2_corinthians/2-11.htm
“some of his crafty contrivances and designs are known, though not all of them; and this particularly, that he sometimes transforms himself into an angel of light, and under pretence of showing a just indignation against sin, and keeping up a strict and righteous discipline, destroys souls, ruins churches, and brings religion into contempt. This was one of his devices in former times, that persons who fell into any gross sin after baptism, and a profession of religion, were never to be restored and received into the communion of the church again, let their repentance be ever so sincere.”
I quite agree. I’ve often said that once this snap back of the pendulum occurs it will be the Kinist who are trying to make sure that it doesn’t snap back too far or too hard.
Those were some good book recommendations for Doug.
If he wants to go back even further, he may want to read Justin Martyr’s “Dialogue with Trypho”. He may even want to look into the origin and purpose of freemasonry (43 AD). German literati knew the churches had been infiltrated, and reacted against the antichristian element. In some cases (not all) orthodoxy was lost in the reaction, but this has been overstated in the interest of keeping the wool over the eyes of those like David Jeremiah, who are forever quoting Gen. 12:3 without any mention of Gal. 3:16.
“The decisive days of the year 1933 saw a peculiar historical drama in Germany – the clashing of two revolutions, a renaissance and an insurrection, the violent collision of which crushed and destroyed the hitherto existing form of government. The nation remained triumphant on the field. It had not fought only for itself, for its freedom and its future; it felt it was bearing arms for all Western Christian nations in a war against Bolshevism. The decisive battle between faith and godlessness, between national consciousness and internationalism, between spirit, honor and character on the one side, and bestiality, dishonor and crime on the other, was fought on German soil.” p. 177.
Adolf Ehrt, ‘Communism in Germany’, published by the General League of German Anti-Communist Associations, 1933
I’ve listened to Corey and Woe. What is it they’ve said that you found ‘unhinged’?
And thanks so much for your enlightening emails.
Marilyn
Hello Marilyn,
Recently they said (paraphrasing) that the gods the ancient Europeans worshiped (like Oden & Thor) was a worship that was accepted by the God of the Bible.
I also think they have been Aryan like in some of their extreme condemnations of the Jews. Some of the stuff they say finds me understanding why people characterize them as National Socialists.
RC anti-Protestant propaganda has for a long time claimed that the deepest and truest reason for Lutheran reformation was simply xenophobic German nationalism that sought scriptural excuses and pretexts for its abandonment of the universal Catholic church. This anti-Lutheran narrative was later taken over by liberals and Jews.
But some Lutheran individuals apparently, both back in the days of Third Reich and now today, wish to bring this hostile stereotype to life by being overly accommodating to Germanic tribalism.
The American Blacks, of course, are a notorious example of ethnic sentiments being the number one reason for the existence of their churches and theology a distant second. Like in the case of Christ-rejecting Jews (Romans 11:20), we should not be high-minded but fear, and make sure not to follow their bad example.