The Error of SCOTUS’ Everson vs. The Board of Education

“Neither a state nor the Federal Government can set up a church. Neither can pass laws which aid one religion, aid all religions, or prefer one religion over another … In the words of Jefferson, the clause against establishment of religion by law was intended to erect ‘a wall of separation between Church and State.”

Everson vs. Board of Education (1947)
SCOTUS Decision

1.) This decision preferred the religion of no religion over any other religion. For a government to be religion-less is impossible as their decision reveals.

2.) Laws are morality enacted. Morality is determined by religion. Therefore all laws, by definition, aid some religion and end up preferring one religion over another. SCOTUS in 1947 preferred to aid the religion that would not allow the Christian religion to be ascendent.

3.) Jefferson was only saying to the Danbury Baptists that the FEDS could not make any one denominational expression of Christianity to be the established denomination. States were allowed to have established churches. This interpretation is sustained by the words of SCOTUS Judge Joseph Story,

“The real object of the amendment was not to countenance, much less to advance Mahometanism, of Judaism, or infidelity, by prostrating Christianity; but to exclude all rivalry among Christian sects, and to prevent any national ecclesiastical establishment, which should give patronage to any hierarchy the exclusive patronage of the national government.”

Joseph Story
Commentaries on the Constitution II.634 (1833)
Associate justice of SCOTUS from 1812 to 1845

4.) There is a difference between not having an established church (denomination) and not having an established religion. America was established as a Christian nation that refused to allow the FEDS to nominate any one denomination in America to be the required church denomination.

The US Constitution did not disestablish Christianity as the religion of the nation as was testified by the sundry state constitutions which mandated that magistrates declare their faith in God or the Christian religion (New Hampshire and South Carolina explicitly). Delaware, Maryland, and Pennsylvania’s 1776 constitutions mandated that officeholders profess faith in Jesus Christ, while states like Georgia and South Carolina explicitly required adherence to the Protestant religion.

In light of that we understand that contrary to Everson vs. Board of Education there was no wall of Separation between religion and state. That is seen even in our own US Constitution as it recognized the Lord’s Day (Sunday) as the Christian Sabbath by appointing it as a day of rest from conducting official government business (art. 1, sec. 7) while simultaneously recognizing the Christian Calendar, finishing the document with, “DONE in the Year of our Lord….”

Everson vs. The Board of Education was adjudicated by men who were not only stupid, but by men who were historically illiterate. Alternately, it was adjudicated by men who had an axe to grind against the Christian faith.

McAtee Contra S. Wolfe on The Relation Between Theology & Politics

Yes, turning to Christ is a necessary condition for good politics.

But good theology does not automatically make good politics. You might think that it logically does. I doubt it, because I distinguish theology and politics. Being pro or anti immigration is not determined properly by the Gospel.

Regardless, we all know that saving faith in Christ does not itself cause in everyone a political will for mass deportations. There are believers who support immigration. I will not deny their salvation on account of that political disagreement.

Something in addition to saving faith produces the political will we need.”

Stephen Wolfe
Post on X

Let’s break this down.

SW writes,

Yes, turning to Christ is a necessary condition for good politics.

BLMc

Well, at least he conceded this much.

SW writes,

But good theology does not automatically make good politics. You might think that it logically does. I doubt it, because I distinguish theology and politics. Being pro or anti immigration is not determined properly by the Gospel.

BLMc

1.) “Good” theology that doesn’t automatically make for good politics is by definition NOT good theology.

2.) Wolfe does not distinguish theology from politics. Wolfe divorces theology from politics. There is a difference.

3.) Being pro or anti immigrant may not be determined by the Gospel, narrowly considered, but they certainly are determined by the Biblically Christian faith. Wolfe has an inability to see that the Christian faith cannot be reduced to “the Gospel,” although there is no Christian faith without the Gospel.

SW writes,

Regardless, we all know that saving faith in Christ does not itself cause in everyone a political will for mass deportations. There are believers who support immigration. I will not deny their salvation on account of that political disagreement.

BLMc

Sure, there are all kinds of believers in Christ who have not yet matured in the Christian faith in any number of areas. But that doesn’t mean that Christianity does NOT teach, per God’s revelation that suiciding your nation is evil.

SW writes,

Something in addition to saving faith produces the political will we need.

BLMc responds,

Yes … and that something is called Biblical Christianity. Wolfe, to the contrary, insists that something is right reason and natural law.

Answering Kevin De Young’s Six Questions on Christian Nationalism

Kevin De Young wrote,

1.) Do you unequivocally renounce antisemitism, racism, and Nazism?

2.) When and how does the nation act as a corporate moral person?
3.) What is the purpose of civil government?
4.) What does it mean for the civil magistrate to promote true religion?
5.) Was the First Amendment a mistake?
6.) What is the historical example of the political order you would like to see in America?

Kevin De Young
Six Questions for Christian Nationalists

1.) Unequivocally? No … and that because those terms are merely pejoratives that the left uses in order to shut down conversation. To the left everyone who disagrees with them are “racists, antisemites, and Nazis.” I am not going to be dictated in my beliefs by the insults of the far left.

2.) Every time it passes laws.

3.) To glorify the God of the Bible and no other God and to do so by acting as God’s enforcer of justice bringing justice by God’s standards.

4.) “The Magistrates office is not only to have regard unto and watch for the welfare of the civil state, but also that they protect the sacred ministry, and thus may remove and prevent all idolatry and false worship; that the kingdom of antichrist may be thus destroyed and the kingdom of Christ promoted. Magistrates must, therefore, countenance the preaching of the word of the gospel everywhere, that God may be honored and worshipped by every one, as He commands in His Word.”  (Belgic Confession Article 36)

5.) No, because the 1st amendment only applied to the FEDS and presupposed that the states would be Christian states. The states could and often did have established denominations. The purpose of the 1st amendment was to keep the FEDS from naming any one denominational expression of Christianity from being the established denomination. However, it was understood that since the State were Christian the nation would be Christian.

Listen to Supreme Court Justice Joseph Storey here,

“Indeed, in a republic, there would seem to be a peculiar propriety in viewing the Christian religion as the great basis on which it must rest for its support and permanence, if it be, what it has ever been deemed by its truest friends to be, the religion of liberty.”

“[O]r it may establish the doctrines of a particular sect as exclusively the religion of the state, tolerating others to a limited extent, or excluding all not belonging to it from all public honors, trusts, emoluments, privileges, and immunities.”

Joseph Storey
Associate justice of the Supreme Court of the United States from 1812 to 1845

6.) 1789 America w/ the one change of inserting the Lordship of Jesus Christ into the Constitution.

Continuing to Expose De Young’s Soft Underbelly

“Religious nationalism, by contrast, usually calls for the state to protect the religious interests of one group, while marginalizing or suppressing other groups. “In so doing,” Marshall explains, “it treats the members of the dominant religion and/or language, ethnicity, and culture as the core citizens and others as second class.”

Kevin De Young
6 Questions for Christian Nationalists

We already have this. We have what De Young calls “religious nationalism.” We have the state protecting the religious interests of one group (the polytheists) while it is, at the same time, marginalizing or suppressing Biblical Christianity’s demand that we should be ruled by laws and principles rooted in God’s revelation. Indeed, as I (and many others) have said ad nauseam, it is not possible to not have a state that protects the religious interests of one group while it simultaneously marginalizes the religious interests of another group. The neutrality that De Young pines for is a myth.

Right now, White Christians are being treated as second class citizens. This is what all the statistics from the white replacement reality has been pointing. White people, and especially White Christians are being treated as second class citizens. The affirmative action legislation which favors non-whites, the defunding of American whites in order to pay for the current immigrant invasion, the whole WOKE ideology pushed in Government universities all testify to the fact that De Young can’t see, and that is that we currently have a religious nationalism (humanistic polytheism) that favors non-Christians and non-Whites.

De Young, by not recognizing this and identifying it and by favoring a kind of bogus governmental neutrality, is bringing that mindset into the Church and calling it “Christianity.”

He is doing irreparable harm to the body of Christ.

Examining Kevin De Young’s Anti-Christian Nationalism Speech VII

“I remember the late Voddie Baucham giving a talk and saying the only two choices we have are pagan nationalism and Christian Nationalism. I don’t think that is the most helpful way to frame the debate, but that gets a lot of traction with a lot of people.

‘OK, you’re not for Christian nationalism? I guess your for pagan globalism.’

Those are the two opposites. ‘Well, no, I’m not for (pagan globalism).’

Well, if you’re not for pagans running it, don’t you want Christians? And if you don’t want Christ on the throne, who do you want on the throne.”

Kevin De Young
“I Hate Christian Nationalism” Screed
TGC conference

This kind of thinking that De Young criticizes is the thinking of what is known as “The Reformed anti-thesis.” It finds its roots in Jesus saying,

He who is not with Me is against Me, and he who does not gather with Me scatters abroad.  — Matthew 12:30

And again,

He who is not with Me is against Me, and he who does not gather with Me scatters abroad.  — Matthew 6:24

The idea here is that there is no neutral ground. As applied to this subject either one is advocating for some version of Christian Nationalism or they are advocating for some version of Pagan nationalism. Kev says this isn’t the best way to frame the matter but Kev says that because he doesn’t want that kind of clear cut demarcation. Notice that De Young never gives an alternative to this framing. He merely says it is not the best way to frame it.

Let me say it bluntly. De Young is for pagan globalism or pagan nationalism, but he wants it in a way where it is kind of diluted by some remnants of a Christian garnish. De Young is looking for a hybrid wherein we can still call what we have “Christian,” but in point of fact is thorough going paganism. He wants a pagan social order that has a patina of a Christian gloss on it. Kev, in point of fact, does not want Christ on the throne.

___

“We were talking throughout the break (and asking) what’s the bigger threat. You know, the radical right or the progressive left. The answer, of course, depends on the denomination you’re part of, and where you are. And I was, you know, I’m thinking in my head, ‘Stephen Wolfe,’ and, you know, all the guys online and the dangers of CN that I’ve written about. And these dear saints in my church are thinking people who want to drive Christianity out of the public square and don’t want prayer…”

Kevin De Young
Anti CN screed
TGC

This is an incredible admission from De Young and demonstrates how far on the left the man is. This man thinks that Stephen Wolfe’s rather tepid Christian Nationalism is a bigger threat to our current social order then those who want to drive Christianity out of the public square. Well, this shouldn’t be surprising since De Young is infected with R2K, Now, De Young isn’t as far down the drain as a R. Scott Clark or a Chrissy Gordon, but De Young definitely embraces some of the principles of R2K.

It is jaw-dropping that any member of the “conservative” clergy would even toy with the idea that the right is more of a danger to the West or, even the Church, than the left. One has to already be on the left to make that kind of statement.

Another thing to note here that we see with this statement is that De Young is seeking to navigate his position by staking out a hybrid position that he would say is neither “progressive left,” nor, “radical right,” but he is doing so as a man on the left. The only reason he sees the “right” as radical is because his Christianity has been shaped by Enlightenment left worldview. To De Young anyone who desires a “Christian Prince,” or a explicitly Christian government is on the radical right.

De Young’s Christianity has been so interpreted through a Enlightenment left lens that he can’t see that he occupies the the left and so anything that is genuinely conservative, in a historic sense, is to the man the progressive left.

This is where much of our conservative clergy is today in the US. They have reinterpreted Christianity through the grid of the Endarkenment left grid. This is a grid that forbids the God of the Bible from being alone God over the public square. These chaps really are invested in making sure the social order remains polytheistic. They understand that Christian Nationalism is a threat to our current polytheistic political order and they are screaming at the top of their lungs that anybody who disagrees with them is on the radical right and is an enemy of Christ.